Why Dollar General is Poised to Outperform Dollar Tree in the Coming Years

The analysis highlights Dollar General's potential to outperform Dollar Tree in the coming years, driven by expected earnings recovery and strong shareholder returns, while debunking the myth of e-commerce overtaking traditional retailers. Despite current economic challenges, Dollar General's strategic adjustments and consistent capital returns position it as a compelling investment opportunity.
SummaryThe text compares the stock performance of Dollar General and Dollar Tree, predicting that Dollar General will outperform Dollar Tree over the next five years due to its potential for earnings recovery and greater shareholder returns. Despite the narrative that e-commerce is taking over, both companies are adapting to shifts in consumer behavior, with Dollar General showing signs of stabilizing its profits. Additionally, Dollar General’s history of returning more capital to shareholders, including a growing dividend, makes it a more appealing investment. However, The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor team has identified other stocks with potentially higher returns, suggesting investors consider broader options.

The Dollar Store Duel: Dollar General vs. Dollar Tree

The retail sector, particularly the dollar store niche, often appears homogeneous to investors. Over the past decade, the stock performance of Dollar General and Dollar Tree has mirrored each other closely. However, I am convinced that Dollar General will outshine Dollar Tree over the next five years, despite their similar trajectories.

The Power of Earnings Growth

Skepticism abounds when it comes to predicting stock movements. While it’s true that the future is unpredictable, one reliable indicator stands tall: rising earnings tend to drive stock prices upward. This correlation is evident in Dollar General’s 10-year chart, where its earnings per share (EPS) and stock price have moved in tandem.

Currently, Dollar Tree and Dollar General stocks have plummeted 57% and 67%, respectively, from their peak values. Dollar Tree is grappling with a trailing 12-month net loss, while Dollar General’s EPS has nosedived by over 40%. The drop in stock prices aligns with the decline in profits, underscoring the significance of predicting earnings for these companies. I foresee Dollar General as the superior choice, with prospects of substantial earnings recovery and enhanced shareholder returns.

Debunking the E-commerce Myth

A pervasive narrative suggests that e-commerce is devouring the market share of traditional retailers like Dollar General and Dollar Tree. This belief is often backed by Amazon’s robust financial outcomes. However, the reality is different. According to Dollar Tree’s 2024 second-quarter report, the company has welcomed nearly 3 million new shoppers in the past year. Although Dollar General hasn’t released similar statistics, its growth in same-store sales contradicts the e-commerce threat.

Amazon’s retail segment is also witnessing a shift, with consumers opting for more affordable items—a trend mirrored by Dollar Tree and Dollar General. Both companies have observed that customers, constrained financially, are prioritizing essential purchases over discretionary ones. This behavior shift doesn’t equate to losing customers but rather adapting to their changing needs.

Projecting Profits: What’s Next?

Dollar General anticipates its full-year EPS to settle at a minimum of $5.50, a significant drop from previous forecasts. However, there are signs that the company’s earnings may have bottomed out. J.P. Morgan Research indicates a growing possibility of a recession before year’s end, with a 35% probability. Dollar General’s historical earnings trends align with this, often dipping right before a recession.

Economic data typically lags behind real-world changes, meaning consumer behavior shifts before official statistics capture the trend. Therefore, Dollar General’s financial recovery often precedes official recession conclusions. Furthermore, the company is tackling internal issues that have dented profits, such as excess inventory leading to markdowns and losses. The return of former CEO Todd Vasos is aimed at rectifying these challenges, with inventory levels gradually normalizing.

As consumer spending rebounds, both Dollar Tree and Dollar General are likely to see profit improvements. However, Dollar General may gain an additional edge from resolving its inventory problems. Additionally, Dollar General’s history of returning more capital to shareholders sets it apart. While both companies repurchase shares, Dollar General’s rapidly growing dividend offers an extra incentive.

Conclusion: A Promising Future for Dollar General

In summary, the core concept of dollar stores remains robust, with current consumer behavior shifts driven by economic conditions. As these trends potentially reverse, Dollar General may benefit significantly, especially by addressing its inventory challenges. While Dollar Tree is poised to experience similar advantages, Dollar General’s consistent shareholder returns position it as a more attractive investment today.

Investment Considerations

Before investing in Dollar General, it’s worth noting that The Motley Fool’s Stock Advisor team has identified ten stocks they believe are prime investments now, and Dollar General is not among them. The selected stocks have the potential for substantial returns, as evidenced by the inclusion of Nvidia in April 2005, which would have turned a $1,000 investment into $710,860.

Stock Advisor provides a comprehensive investment strategy, with regular updates and new stock recommendations, offering a return more than four times that of the S&P 500 since 2002.

Explore the top 10 stocks ›

Stock Advisor returns as of September 17, 2024

Henry Lawson
Henry Lawson

Henry Lawson: The Sage of Screen Stories

At 50, Henry Lawson stands as a seasoned pillar in the realm of TV entertainment journalism, offering a wealth of experience and a discerning eye cultivated over decades of reporting. With his distinguished brown hair, now gently touched by the wisdom of silver, Henry has become a trusted name for insightful television news and analysis.

Born and raised in the culturally rich city of New Orleans, Louisiana, Henry's early years were steeped in the vibrant narratives of southern storytelling—a heritage that sparked his lifelong love for the art of narrative. His fascination with television began with classic shows of the '70s and '80s, which he watched with his family, fostering a deep appreciation for the evolution of storytelling on the small screen.

Henry pursued his passion academically at New York University, where he majored in Media Studies. After graduating, he embarked on a storied career that saw him writing for some of the most prestigious entertainment publications in the industry. His articles are known for their depth, blending historical context with current trends to provide a comprehensive view of the ever-evolving television landscape.

Having witnessed the seismic shifts from network dominance to the streaming revolution, Henry has become an authority on the subject, often called upon for his commentary on television panels and podcasts. His work not only covers the latest news but also delves into the cultural impact of television, exploring how it reflects and shapes society.

Outside of his professional endeavors, Henry is a devoted family man. He shares his life with his wife, Clara, a talented painter, and their two children, both of whom have inherited their parents' artistic inclinations. Family movie nights remain a cherished tradition, where classic films and new series alike are enjoyed and discussed in detail.

An avid jazz enthusiast, Henry spends his free time attending local jazz festivals and playing the saxophone, a nod to his New Orleans roots. He also enjoys gardening, finding peace and inspiration in cultivating his backyard oasis, where he often retreats to brainstorm his next article.

Henry Lawson's career is a testament to his enduring passion for television and storytelling. As he continues to chronicle the ever-changing world of TV entertainment, his readers rely on his seasoned perspective to navigate the complex tapestry of stories that captivate audiences around the globe.

Articles: 28

Related Posts