Exploring High-Yield REITs: Stability vs. Growth with AGNC and EPR Properties

This text evaluates the investment prospects of AGNC Investment and EPR Properties, two REITs with high dividend yields. AGNC offers stable dividends but limited growth, while EPR combines attractive dividends with growth potential through strategic investments. It also highlights The Motley Fool's successful stock recommendations, encouraging investors to seize high-return opportunities.
SummaryThe text compares two dividend-focused real estate investment trusts (REITs), AGNC Investment and EPR Properties. AGNC Investment offers a high dividend yield of over 13% but lacks dividend growth, relying solely on stable monthly payouts. In contrast, EPR Properties, with a yield over 7%, focuses on experiential real estate and is poised for growth through strategic investments and rental income escalation. EPR’s potential for dividend increases and stock appreciation makes it a more dynamic option for investors seeking growth. Additionally, the text highlights The Motley Fool Stock Advisor’s high-performing investment recommendations, emphasizing opportunities to “double down” on promising stocks with proven substantial returns.

High-Yield Dividend Stocks: A Closer Look at AGNC Investment and EPR Properties

AGNC Investment, with a dividend yield of 1.16%, is a standout among dividend stocks, especially given its focus on mortgage-backed real estate. The real estate investment trust (REIT) is currently offering a dividend yield exceeding 13%, which is notably ten times the yield of the S&P 500. Investors of AGNC benefit from monthly dividend payments, creating a lucrative stream of passive income.

AGNC Investment: Stability Over Growth

Despite the attractive dividend, AGNC Investment does have its limitations. A significant drawback is the REIT’s lack of dividend growth. Investors primarily rely on the stable monthly dividend for returns, without the expectation of dividend increases.

For investors seeking more dynamic growth, EPR Properties, another REIT, presents an interesting alternative. EPR Properties provides a high-yield monthly dividend of over 7%, with potential for growth as it expands its portfolio and increases cash flow per share.

The Income Formula of AGNC

AGNC Investment currently pays its investors $0.12 per share each month, amounting to $1.44 annually. This payout has remained consistent since the REIT reduced its dividend during the pandemic. Historically, AGNC has adjusted its dividends in response to economic factors:

AGNC’s strategy involves investing in mortgage-backed securities (MBS) supported by government agencies. The REIT faces challenges from interest rate fluctuations and other economic factors affecting earnings. For instance, when interest rates fall, borrowers often refinance their mortgages, decreasing AGNC’s interest income and impacting earnings per share, which can lead to dividend cuts.

Despite these challenges, AGNC has managed to deliver solid returns. Though its stock price has declined by 45% since its 2008 launch, the REIT has achieved a total return of 450%, translating to an annualized return of 11%, solely from dividends.

AGNC’s dividend is considered stable for the time being, aided by recent interest rate reductions from the Federal Reserve, which should lower borrowing costs. However, investors should not expect significant stock price appreciation as AGNC continues issuing shares to fund new MBS investments.

EPR Properties: A Potential for Exciting Returns

EPR Properties is a specialty REIT that focuses on experiential real estate, including movie theaters, attractions, lodging, and other entertainment venues. The REIT leases these properties to operating companies under long-term net leases, where tenants cover operating costs like maintenance, insurance, and taxes. EPR’s leases often include rental escalators, typically increasing rents by 1.5% to 2% annually or 7.5% to 10% every five years.

These leases provide EPR Properties with a steady stream of rising rental income, laying the foundation for potential dividend increases. EPR also pursues growth through strategic investments, planning to allocate $200 million to $300 million for new ventures this year. In the first quarter alone, the REIT invested $85 million, including $33.4 million in an attraction property and $14.7 million for land acquisitions and financing for two build-to-suit projects. In the second quarter, EPR continued its momentum, investing $46.9 million primarily in experiential developments.

These initiatives position EPR to expand its funds from operations (FFO) by an estimated 3.2% at the midpoint this year. This growth enabled a 3.6% dividend increase earlier. EPR anticipates sustaining FFO growth with investments funded through post-dividend free cash flow, capital recycling, and its robust balance sheet. As interest rates decrease and capital costs lower, EPR could accelerate growth with external funding, potentially boosting its investment capacity. Even with modest growth, EPR’s strategy supports potential share price appreciation, with total returns potentially exceeding 10% annually. Since its inception in 1997, EPR has delivered a remarkable total return of over 1,300%.

Conclusion: Choosing Between Stability and Growth

AGNC Investment offers investors a stable, lucrative monthly dividend, acting as a fixed-income investment. However, the lack of growth potential means dividends will likely account for the entire return.

For those seeking greater excitement and upside potential, EPR Properties is an appealing choice. In addition to a high monthly dividend, EPR is positioned to grow its income and dividends, offering potential stock price appreciation and lucrative dividends. This makes EPR a compelling option for investors aiming to increase their wealth and income.

Investment Opportunity: Double Down on High-Performing Stocks

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor has achieved a total average return of 762%, significantly outperforming the S&P 500’s 167% since 2002. The analyst team has a proven track record of identifying opportunities to double down on high-potential stocks, resulting in impressive returns.

Nvidia: A $1,000 investment when we doubled down in 2009 would now be worth $301,443!

Netflix: A $1,000 investment when we doubled down in 2004 would have grown to $380,400!

Apple: A $1,000 investment when we doubled down in 2008 would be valued at $42,842!

Currently, we’re issuing “Double Down” alerts for three exceptional companies. Opportunities like these are rare, so take advantage of this chance.

See the stocks ›

Stock Advisor returns as of 09/25/2024

Aya Kimura
Aya Kimura

Aya Kimura: The Screen's Storyteller

At 26, Aya Kimura is a rising star in the world of TV entertainment journalism, known for her captivating writing and sharp analytical prowess. With her striking black hair and an infectious enthusiasm for storytelling, Aya brings a unique and vibrant perspective to the television news landscape.

Born and raised in San Francisco, California, Aya grew up in a household that cherished creativity and cultural diversity. Her parents, both avid film enthusiasts, introduced her early on to a variety of genres and styles, instilling in her a deep appreciation for the power of visual storytelling. This early exposure ignited a passion that would shape her future career.

Aya pursued her love for media and storytelling at UCLA, where she majored in Communications. During her college years, she launched a popular podcast that delved into both mainstream and niche television shows, quickly gaining a dedicated following for her engaging discussions and insightful critiques.

Now a well-regarded journalist, Aya writes for a leading entertainment website, covering everything from the latest series premieres to in-depth interviews with industry insiders. Her articles are celebrated for their blend of cultural commentary and personal reflection, often exploring how television reflects and influences societal trends.

Outside of her professional life, Aya is an advocate for environmental sustainability, often volunteering with local organizations that focus on conservation and green initiatives. Her passion for the planet is a recurring theme in her writing, where she highlights shows that address environmental issues and promote eco-friendly practices.

In her personal time, Aya enjoys practicing yoga and exploring the culinary scene in her city, always on the lookout for new flavors and experiences to share with her readers. She is also an amateur photographer, capturing the vibrant street life and natural beauty of San Francisco through her lens.

With a keen eye for storytelling and a commitment to authenticity, Aya Kimura continues to make her mark in the world of television journalism. Her work not only informs but also inspires, encouraging her audience to see the world of TV through a fresh and insightful lens. As she continues to grow her career, Aya's voice promises to be a guiding light in the ever-evolving landscape of television entertainment.

Articles: 25